By Luis Escobar
March 3, 2007
San Juan, Puerto Rico (Coliseo Roberto Clemente) — Perhaps it was the full moon but Miguel Cotto’s odd TKO victory over the veteran German Oktay Urkal proved once again the open scoring is not the way to go in professional boxing.
The WBA welterweight champion, Cotto repeatedly hammered the 37-year-old Urkal around the ring but he was unable to drop the challenger. Trailing badly on points and penalized for repeatedly using his head in close quarters, Urkal’s evening ended when his trainer Ulli Wegner climbed up on the ring apron waving a white towel.
Fully aware that Urkal would be unable to beat the champion because he knew the score, Wegner surrendered and ended the 147-pound title fight in a move that could only be described as anticlimactic. The Puerto Rican boxing officials announced the scores to the crowd following the 4th and the 8th rounds, much to the dismay and consternation of anyone with a wit of boxing experience, or expertise.
Speaking with the aid of a translator, Wegner conveyed his frustration with the officiating and his charge that Cotto repeatedly landed kidney punches throughout the fight that the referee did nothing to stop.
“The other one was leading through all the rounds and he was doing punches that are not allowed. And the judging allowed it [to] slide,” Wegner translator explained. “He [Urkal] was totally red and blue in the back and that is what I was talking about. I definitely was opened by the open scoring but I also have to say that Cotto is a world class fighter. My fighter did not have a chance with this judge in the ring.”
Cotto did not escape unscathed and in the 5th, he suffered a cut over his left eye that left him bleeding, as a result of a headbutt. Just like everyone else, Cotto was somewhat surprised when the bout was halted.
“I’m a little bit confused with the head of my opponent and he [Wegner] thinks they should stop the fight,” Cotto said after the win. “I don’t know if he did it [intentionally or not] but he hit me with his head. In a few moments of the early rounds the blood bothered me.”
–Full Moon Rising–
The mandatory challenger from Berlin, Urkal (38-4, 11 KO’s) entered the ring with a 0-3 record in title fights and he exited with another goose egg on his resume.
Cotto (29-0, 24 KO’s) repeatedly scored in the opening round with a variety of digging body shots that thudded off the challenger’s midsection and within the first minute, Urkal (146) was turning and complaining to the referee Luis Pabon about the location of the Puerto Rican’s heavy lumber. Urkal returned fire with stiff jabs and right hands down the middle but with 1:07 to go in the 1st, he was drilled with a sharp left hook to the liver.
In the opening moments on the 2nd, Cotto, Caguas, Puerto Rico dipped at the waist and got extra leverage with a whistling right hand that detonated off of the challenger’s ribcage. The champion returned to winging in hard body shots and Urkal answered by firing low and blasting Cotto with a crisp left hook below the belt and then falling into a clinch. Both men continued to trade body shots and with 1:46 remaining in the 2nd, Cotto, 26, clipped Urkal with a solid left hook to the chin.
A left uppercut to the face caught Urkal on the jaw and the crowd responded with the necessary groans but the challenger seemed unfazed with Cotto’s power. With 1:06 remaining in the round, Urkal stepped inside and unloaded a sharp four-punch combination before reloading and firing another salvo. The challenger attempted to defend his body by tucking in his elbows and using his arms as shields. However, with 29-seconds remaining in the round, Cotto landed a left hook to the face before dropping low and landing another blast just above the challenger’s beltline. At the bell, Urkal held out his glove in a display of mutual respect, however, Cotto was not in the mood to exchange pleasantries.
Cotto returned to banging away the body whenever the opportunity permitted and to his credit the veteran challenger repeatedly was able to answer, counter and fire combinations. However, at times it appeared as if Cotto was so strong and so focused he simply walked through Urkal’s punches, intent on landing his own screaming shots.
Early in the 4th, Cotto tagged the challenger with a right hand to the ear followed by a solid left hook to the body. Urkal attempted to cover up, however, the champion staggered the challenger with a short but swift left jab on the button. The punch drove Urkal backwards and the crowd roared in anticipation of more heavy artillery from the local island hero. Cotto flurried and scored with another crisp combination and the only thing that Urkal hit was reverse. The challenger responded with two sharp right hands but the champion simply walked through the punches and answered by firing leather.
Cotto repeatedly landed hammering shots and with 1:02 to go in the 4th, once again he unloaded a vicious right hand to the body that seemingly curved around Urkal’s left elbow and exploded off of his bottom rib. Urkal answered with two of his body shots but it was the champion who scored with the heavier leather. The challenger continued to lean inside and in the next exchange the referee Pabón called time and warned the challenger about using his head in close quarters. Two more searing body blasts thudded off of Urkal’s torso and he was driven into the ropes. Just before the bell to end the 4th, Cotto wobbled the challenger with a short left uppercut to the chin that rocked Urkal back on his heels and into the ropes.
After the conclusion of the fourth round the score with announced to crowd with Cotto leading on all three cards, 40-36.
–Billy Goat Time–
Cotto went right back to work doing what he does best; and at the 2:34 mark of the 5th, he ripped Urkal with a scorching left hook just above the liver. The champion continued to tattoo the German with blazing body shots and Urkal’s frustration to being on the receiving end of so much heavy lumber took a turn. With 1:28 to go in the round, Cotto dropped low to land a punch, as did the challenger, however, Urkal led with his head and caught the champion with the top of his skull over his left eye. Cotto winced in pain and blood began dripping from the wound, as the referee Pabon separated the boxers.
Cotto answered with a little more than a minute to go and tagged the German with an arcing left hook flush on the jaw. Urkal attempted to cover but he was forced to return fire after the champion unloaded a whistling four-shot sequence to the ribs that was not for the feint of heart. Just before the bell to end of the round, there was another clash of heads and Cotto again was caught over his left eye by Urkal’s skull.
Between rounds, Cotto’s cutman Miguel Diaz went to work on the champion’s damaged left eye and the local hero gestured at his opponent and the referee Pabon while sitting on his stool.
Cotto jolted Urkal at the 2:02 mark of the 6th, with a rapid-fire three shots combination that richochtted off of the challenger’s skull. However, after the German retreated to the ropes and the champion landed several more digging body shots, Urkal lowered his shoulder and his head. Urkal simply used his skull as a battering ram to escape his confinement. The referee Pabon called time and cautioned the boxer not to use his head as a third glove.
Blood continue to drip down Cotto’s damaged left eye and began effecting his vision, nevertheless, he was resolute and returned to firing searing body shots that made you wonder if the German was wearing armor plating. With 1:51 to go in the round, Urkal clearly attempted to use his head to butt the champion and referee called time and issued his second warning.
Given that Cotto was clearly bleeding and with open scoring everyone was aware of just how far Urkal was behind on the judges’ scorecards, it seemed the only logical but illegal tactic left for him to try.
–Body Work–
The champion simply returned to firing merciless left hooks that looked like tracer rounds as they hit the target and seemingly shook the challenger every time they landed.
With 1:36 remaining in the 7th, Cotto just about carved his initials into Urkal’s hide with a searing left hook to the body and the sound of the blast just stopped shy of echoing into the cool evening air. Urkal responded by clinching and then using his skull to rub against the left side of the champion’s face. The referee Pabon stepped inside and deducted a point from the challenger for headbutting.
Blood continue to drip from the corner of Cotto’s left eye for the remainder of the evening. Everytime that Diaz seemed to halt the flow of blood, once again the champion would return to banging away in close quarters and the slice would reopen. With 13-seconds to go in the round, Cotto sank a right hand into the German’s flank and Urkal answered with a noticeable car wash move of using his skull to try and scrape against the champion’s profile. The referee called time and had the ringside doctor examine the wound. After a quick exam the action resumed and Cotto responded by whacking Urkal with yet another shot to the ribcage.
Just before the bell to end the 8th, Cotto became angry with the challenger and his head banging style, and he nailed Urkal with a left hand to the kidneys. The challenger grimaced in pain, rubbed his back and with the fans standing and screaming Urkal managed to land one more headbutt as the bell sounded.
Pabon had simply lost control and the fouling was so over the top, he could have easily deducted another point or disqualified the challenger, however, the referee let the fouling and the infractions continue.
In the 9th, Cotto nearly removed Urkal’s head from his shoulders as he caught the challenger leaning inside and he ripped the German with a skull snapping left uppercut just under the chin. Amazingly, Urkal gestured to bring it on and Cotto responded over the last several rounds by scoring with enough screaming body shots to make a number of ringsiders wince when everytime the punches landed.
Cotto’s frustration almost spilled over at the end of the 10th, when he ducked low and Urkal’s momentum carried him forward and up on the champion’s shoulders. Cotto lifted Urkal off the canvas in a fireman carry before disgustedly dropping the German back down to the floor.
Cotto returned to blasting away at both sides of the challenger’s flanks in the 11th, however, with Urkal so far behind on all the judges’ scorecards, his trainer Wegner decided to pull the plug. As soon as the ref took another point away from the challenger for using his skull Urkal’s night had come to a conclusion and Wegner started waving his towel.
Cotto had retained his crown, open scoring was yet a failure again and the full moon beamed down upon Puerto Rico. The only thing you could be sure of was that neither Miguel Cotto, or Oktay Urkal would be exchanging Christmas cards next December.
Source